| By Tenure Length | By Position | |||||||
| Player | Team | Pos | Tenure | Player | Team | Pos | Tenure | |
| Delgado, Carlos 1B FLA | BOUNT | 1B | 4F | First Basemen | ||||
| Helton, Todd 1B COL | YC | 1B | 4F | Delgado, Carlos 1B FLA | BOUNT | 1B | 4F | |
| Jones, Chipper 3B ATL | STONE | 3B/OF | 4F | Helton, Todd 1B COL | YC | 1B | 4F | |
| Posada, Jorge C NYY | PK | C | 4F | Thome, Jim 1B PHI | HH | 1B | 3 | |
| Guerrero, Vladimir RF ANA | LO | OF | 4F | Konerko, Paul 1B CHW | HH | 1B | 3 | |
| Sheffield, Gary RF NYY | MR S | OF | 4F | Pujols, Albert 1B STL | LO | 1B | 3 | |
| Ramirez, Manny LF BOS | TTS | OF | 4F | Second Basemen | ||||
| Schilling, Curt SP BOS | LO | SP | 4F | Vidro, Jose 2B WAS | STONE | 2B | 3 | |
| Johnson, Randy SP NYY | STONE | SP | 4F | Soriano, Alfonso 2B TEX | TSM | 2B | 3 | |
| Mussina, Mike SP NYY | TTS | SP | 4F | Shortstops | ||||
| Garciaparra, Nomar SS CHC | BOUNT | SS | 4F | Garciaparra, Nomar SS CHC | BOUNT | SS | 4F | |
| Tejada, Miguel SS BAL | MR S | SS | 4F | Tejada, Miguel SS BAL | MR S | SS | 4F | |
| Rodriguez, Alex 3B NYY | PK | SS | 4F | Jeter, Derek SS NYY | YC | SS | 4F | |
| Jeter, Derek SS NYY | YC | SS | 4F | Third Basemen | ||||
| Thome, Jim 1B PHI | HH | 1B | 3 | Rodriguez, Alex 3B NYY | PK | 3B | 4F | |
| Konerko, Paul 1B CHW | HH | 1B | 3 | Jones, Chipper 3B ATL | STONE | 3B/OF | 4F | |
| Pujols, Albert 1B STL | LO | 1B | 3 | Chavez, Eric 3B OAK | MR S | 3B | 3 | |
| Vidro, Jose 2B WAS | STONE | 2B | 3 | Catchers | ||||
| Soriano, Alfonso 2B TEX | TSM | 2B | 3 | Posada, Jorge C NYY | PK | C | 4F | |
| Chavez, Eric 3B OAK | MR S | 3B | 3 | Lieberthal, Mike C PHI | SF | C | 3 | |
| Lieberthal, Mike C PHI | SF | C | 3 | Outfielders | ||||
| Edmonds, Jim CF STL | HH | OF | 3 | Guerrero, Vladimir RF ANA | LO | OF | 4F | |
| Suzuki, Ichiro RF SEA | PK | OF | 3 | Sheffield, Gary RF NYY | MR S | OF | 4F | |
| Jones, Andruw CF ATL | SF | OF | 3 | Ramirez, Manny LF BOS | TTS | OF | 4F | |
| Anderson, Garret CF ANA | STONE | OF | 3 | Edmonds, Jim CF STL | HH | OF | 3 | |
| Damon, Johnny CF BOS | YC | OF | 3 | Suzuki, Ichiro RF SEA | PK | OF | 3 | |
| Wagner, Billy RP PHI | TTS | RP | 3 | Jones, Andruw CF ATL | SF | OF | 3 | |
| Clemens, Roger SP HOU | BOUNT | SP | 3 | Anderson, Garret CF ANA | STONE | OF | 3 | |
| Halladay, Roy SP TOR | BOUNT | SP | 3 | Damon, Johnny CF BOS | YC | OF | 3 | |
| Morris, Matt SP STL | BOUNT | SP | 3 | Starting Pitchers | ||||
| Zito, Barry SP OAK | HH | SP | 3 | Schilling, Curt SP BOS | LO | SP | 4F | |
| Buehrle, Mark SP CHW | MR S | SP | 3 | Johnson, Randy SP NYY | STONE | SP | 4F | |
| Oswalt, Roy SP HOU | STONE | SP | 3 | Mussina, Mike SP NYY | TTS | SP | 4F | |
| Mulder, Mark SP STL | TTS | SP | 3 | Clemens, Roger SP HOU | BOUNT | SP | 3 | |
| Martinez, Pedro SP NYM | TSM | SP | 3 | Halladay, Roy SP TOR | BOUNT | SP | 3 | |
| Smoltz, John RP ATL | TSM | SP | 3 | Morris, Matt SP STL | BOUNT | SP | 3 | |
| Zito, Barry SP OAK | HH | SP | 3 | |||||
| Buehrle, Mark SP CHW | MR S | SP | 3 | |||||
| Oswalt, Roy SP HOU | STONE | SP | 3 | |||||
| Mulder, Mark SP STL | TTS | SP | 3 | |||||
| Martinez, Pedro SP NYM | TSM | SP | 3 | |||||
| Smoltz, John RP ATL | TSM | SP | 3 | |||||
| Relief Pitchers | ||||||||
| Wagner, Billy RP PHI | TTS | RP | 3 | |||||